An apology received’t carry again the 1000’s of bushes felled in Sheffield

In Sheffield, my dwelling city, the council has ultimately apologised for deceptive the general public, the media and the courts in the course of the dispute over its unfathomably silly and harsh marketing campaign to fell 17,500 of town’s avenue bushes, a lot of which it now accepts had been completely wholesome. This growth is, in fact, welcome, if lengthy overdue. But it surely doesn’t actually change something. Who will ever have the ability to neglect the chainsaws? Beloved limes and sycamores are gone. Most of us will probably be lengthy useless earlier than their replacements attain something like maturity.

Enthusiastic about this horrible, pointless enterprise over again, I’m struck by the default accusations of nimbyism on the council’s half, an angle that persists even now. In its assertion, it mentioned that it had misrepresented those that protested in opposition to the destruction as “primarily solely in their very own streets”.

I do know that is true; most activists cared about neighbourhoods far past their very own. However I additionally marvel why the council believes it may be morally doubtful for an individual to fret about his or her personal avenue? Isn’t this the place neighborhood begins? Every avenue is a part of a village – Sheffield is famously a group of villages – and these villages make up town.

Councils, it appears to me, deploy the phrase neighborhood solely when it fits. Just lately, I waited for an hour on the library to speak to our (Labour) councillor about low visitors zones. As somebody who’s in favour of LTZs, however finds herself sandwiched between two of them, I wished to know the way it’s determined who will profit from such schemes, and who will probably be their victims. However from the second I opened my mouth, I understood I used to be losing my breath. To ask questions, not to mention to have emotions, in regards to the place the place you reside is more and more framed as bare self-interest by politicians on the left, the thought being, I believe, that should you make folks (your personal voters!) really feel imply and thoughtless, disgrace will silence them, and you’ll then get on with doing no matter you want.

To absent pals

A lot missed: Virago’s founder, Carmen Callil. {Photograph}: Eamonn McCabe/The Guardian

To a celebration in Soho to have a good time the fiftieth birthday of Virago books, and the way pretty to search out myself wedged between two of the writers I like most, Hermione Lee and Sarah Waters. Friends have been invited to put on inexperienced in honour of Virago’s well-known livery, and I appear to be a jolly Pacer – the minty candy that ceased manufacturing in 1985 – in a frock with white and sage stripes. However there’s a painful absence: my pal Carmen Callil, the writer’s founder, who died final yr.

Greater than as soon as, I think about I hear the sound of her laughter. How I want she was on this sizzling, crowded room to make wild introductions and even wilder pronouncements – and that we might gossip about this wonderful gathering of girls (and a few males) collectively later.

Severe reservations

You’re booked … {Photograph}: 10’000 Hours/Getty Photographs

The neurotic messages we obtain prematurely of just about any go to to a restaurant – your reserving is approaching; please verify your reserving; thanks for confirming your reserving – are nonetheless annoying. However silence is now no good both, for it induces one’s personal neuroticism.

Having heard nothing since I booked a desk at a brand new Greek restaurant, I resolve to ring them. A person picks up. “I’d like to verify a reserving,” I say. “What?” he asks. “Er, I’m hoping like to verify a reserving,” I repeat, rising the brightness in my voice only a notch. “OK,” he replies. I run via the small print. Silence, after which: “See you tomorrow.”

How refreshing! I believe, hanging up. I have to push from my thoughts the concept our reservation could also be solely as actual as Atlantis, or the Backyard of the Hesperides.

Rachel Cooke is an Observer columnist

Do you might have an opinion on the problems raised on this article? If you want to submit a letter of as much as 250 phrases to be thought of for publication, e mail it to us at